Nazis Not Welcome on Somervell County Salon- That includes Republicans who will not firmly repudiate Nazis and White Supremacists.

- A R Moxon

I have been thinking about how Republicans in the Texas GOP party will not repudiate Nick Fuentes openly. Texas GOP Executive committee rejects proposed ban on associating with Nazi sympathizers and Holocaust deniers. I cannot even imagine it being so difficult for anyone to shun repugnant people and groups such as Nazis. Even with watered down language and half of Texas GOP’s executive committee against this, yet a vote STILL could not be had to denounce this association.

“I just don’t understand how people who routinely refer to others as leftists, liberals, communists, socialists and RINOs (‘Republicans in Name Only’) don’t have the discernment to define what a Nazi is,” committee member Morgan Cisneros Graham told the Tribune after the vote.

And then I came across some excellent comments about a particular online community that has, basically, put out a Nazis Welcome Here on their site (Substack) in the name of *freedom of speech*. But, as these people who wrote about it say, there is a difference between the govt limiting speech and a private site moderating a site. And, we suspect, not doing so, means that being able to make money from writers trumps preventing Nazi talk on their site.

First, from Ken White – Substack Has A Nazi Opportunity; Dealing With Nazis, Or Not, Can Be A Brand. Substack’s Monetizing It.

There’s an infinite number of cranks and lunatics; choosing which ones to promote as plausible is a value judgment. There are people who are eagerly (if not necessarily sincerely) saying that Trump was elected in 2020 or that the Earth is flat; promoting them or not is a value judgment. We all make judgments all the time about which speech is within or without our circle of acceptable decency, speech that is worth sober debate on our own platforms. We should, at a minimum, be honest about it. If “racism is within my circle of decency and debate” is our point, we should make it openly, not evade it.

Techdirt

your reputation as a private site is what you allow. If you allow garbage, you’re a garbage site. If you allow Nazis, you’re a Nazi site. You’re absolutely allowed to do that, but you shouldn’t pretend to be something that you’re not. You should own it, and say “these are our policies, and we realize what our reputation is.”

The Reframe

The notion of a marketplace of ideas selecting the best idea and rejecting the worse is an interesting one. It suggests that marketplaces always select quality, especially the more unregulated they are, which is not something I’ve noticed to be true about how any actual marketplaces operate.

The idea that Nazi “ideas” need to be defeated in open debate, which will cause them to lose power, is also interesting. It presupposes that debates are always won by the most correct idea, which I’ve noticed is often the opposite of how debate works.

It also suggest that Nazis plan is to participate in bloodless debate over their ideas, and accept the outcome if their ideas are rejected, which is not a plan I think Nazis have ever pursued, or the sort of arena in which they have ever admitted—much less accepted—defeat.

It also suggests that what Nazis have are “ideas,” when we know that what they actually have are intentions, and those intentions always create real-life violence toward marginalized communities along racial, ethnic, religious, and other lines of bigotry—and they do so the more effectively Nazis are able to gather and organize and promote their “ideas” into the mainstream.

Most damning of all, it also smuggles in the idea that—in the mind of the person making the suggestion, at least—Nazi ideas haven’t been effectively defeated in the marketplace of ideas yet. Apparently Nazi ideas are still valid and worthy consideration, and need to be debated some more before they are to be considered defeated.

And that is the point. Nazi ideas are not worthy of being considered AT ALL. And certainly if some political party cannot get the stones to denounce this, they too ought to be shunned. This next has some curse words in it, but boy does it hit the mark

Rude Pundit. – If you support Donald Trump, you’re a Nazi

If you’re gonna follow someone whose language lines up with Hitler, who has praised dictators and who wants to bring their methods to the United States, who promises to round up millions of people just trying to live their lives, who threatens to attack our neighbors and break our alliances, who sees non-white people as invaders or criminals who must be dealt with harshly, who wants to “cleanse” the country of people who don’t believe the same shit he does, fuck, yeah, you’re a Nazi. I don’t wanna wait around until gas chambers are built to finally sound an alarm. 

And that’s how the 2024 campaign should go. You can be with the Nazis or you can be with the people who think Nazis deserved to have their asses kicked into the garbage heap. Indeed, history teaches us that we are obligated to kick Nazi asses. If only there was a short, punchy word we could use for anti-facist…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.